Could meditating backfire as a cure for insomnia?

4 Comments

When I find myself awake in the middle of the night, perhaps after a trip to the bathroom or a weird dream, I often practice some kind of meditation to quiet my over-active mind. I’ll usually pay attention to my breathing, or do a body scan, and most times this will help me calm down and nod off.

But could meditating in the middle of the night create its own problems? Someone asked me whether this practice could either lead to us developing the habit of falling asleep during meditation, or keep us awake because mindfulness is so associated with alert attention that we can’t fall asleep.

I don’t think the first is much of a danger; we’re not likely to end up training ourselves to fall asleep in meditation. What happens when we can’t sleep is that intrusive mental activity inhibits the normal physiological mechanism that causes sleep. By being more mindful of the body, we let go of that mental activity, stop inhibiting sleep, and nod off. But in normal meditation (unless you’re already very tired) the physiological mechanism leading to sleep isn’t active, and so you’re not likely to drop off.

Not only can the second problem happen, but it’s something I’ve experienced many times. Meditation isn’t just about relaxation, but involves the arising of counter-balancing “active” qualities like curiosity, interest, and physical arousal. While calmness and relaxation are more likely to predominate when we meditate in order to get to sleep, sometimes alertness will prevail, so that we find ourselves in a “perked up” state that isn’t conducive to nodding off. But if that happens, I think it’s just a signal that we need to take another approach.

I find that visualizing soothing but boring imagery works rather well. For example I’ll imagine rain pattering on the leaves of a tree, on a particularly gray and dismal day. This counteracts the thought patterns and the emotional arousal that prevent sleep from happening, but it makes for a dull experience, and so I don’t get excited about it. I sometimes suspect that I fall asleep just so that I can dream about something more interesting! This isn’t classic meditation, obviously, but it’s a good way of applying the principles of meditation in order to bring about a desired result — in this case a good night’s sleep.

One way that middle-of-the-night meditation has backfired on me has been when I’ve woken from an anxious dream, and taken my attention to the feeling of anxiety. Normally what I’d do is to give the anxiety some compassionate attention, and to sooth myself by being aware of the breathing down in the belly. But recently I’ve found that if I try being mindful in the middle of the night, my experience of the body changes radically. The body’s solidity and sense of form dissolves away, and I’m left with an experience of a translucent cloud of sensations hovering in space. The first couple of times this happened there was a “What the heck?” reaction that led to me remaining awake, seemingly for hours, just observing this phenomenon. But now that I’m used to this happening, I quite quickly get back to sleep again. Perhaps a general lesson is that if using meditation to overcome insomnia doesn’t work at first, keep going. It may be something that you need to persist with.

,

4 Comments. Leave new

  • Yesss, it sure can! I myself had a crisis a little over two years ago, in which I couldn’t stop ‘noticing’ my breathing and ended up averaging two hours of sleep a night, riddled with nightmares, for the space of about a month and a half, until I was finally able to get prescribed an SSRI to calm the hell down. To be fair, I had a lot of stressors in my life at that point, so I don’t think vipassana was the only reason. But, it pretty much did the opposite of calming me down – instead, it amplified existing tendencies towards obsessional thinking, paranoia, confusion, and depersonalization/derealization that lasted for months on end, even after I was on the SSRI.

    There have been times before that and since then when I’ve done a bit of vipassana, and gone into pleasant states of mind, oftentimes spontaneously after the meditation period. So, it’s not ALL bad. But, I want to be a voice out there warning people, if you have an OCD or anxious temperament to begin with, meditation could make it a bad story for you.

    Reply
    • I’m sorry to hear about that experience, Mickey. You might want to talk to Willougbhy Britton, who runs the Dark Night Project, collecting information from people who have had unpleasant or damaging experiences in meditation. I wonder if you’d have had a difference result from lovingkindness meditation? Vipassana is just one tool from a very large toolbox…

      Reply
  • I usually do a body scan or a breath count when I go to bed both to actively relax and to prevent myself from falling into a “review of the day” that might get out of hand. If I do find myself unable to drop off after waking, I will try to relax because even if I don’t drop off, it’s still a lot better than a “tossathon”. The thing I occasionally get is what I would call “anxious body” where I physically feel tremendous unrest and discomfort that I can’t relate to anything mental. I have provoked it in the past by “double dosing” on something like Valerian or Passion Flower and finding that it had the exact opposite of its intended effect, but I have also experienced it when I perhaps went through a mental relaxation, failed to drop off and then went to the opposite pole of anxiety.

    Thankfully, my days of regularly tossing and turning late into a tortured night have become a thing of the past.

    Reply
    • I don’t often get physically restless in bed, Ed, but when it has happened I’ve found it useful to imagine that gravity has been doubled, so that my body is incredibly heavy, and I’m being pulled into the mattress. This makes it natural for my body to be still, and it also acts as a trigger for sleepiness, since the body often feels very heavy when we’re tired. There have been times, though, that I’ve had to accept that I just don’t want to go to sleep!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Menu

Wildmind is a Community-Supported Meditation Initiative. Explore the benefits of becoming a supporter.

X