on practice

Create a space of compassion, and live from it

a view from inside a tower, looking upward. Running upward against the walls of the tower is a spiral staircase supported with pillars. At the top is an opening that looks upward, through leafy tree branches, into the sky.

In the immediate aftermath of the US presidential election, most people I know were shocked. Since then they seem to be making emotional adjustments, which is good.

This is no doubt partly to do with the nature of emotions themselves. Emotions are created by the way we interpret and think about the world. At first, all people could think about was the election, and so their emotional responses were heightened. Quickly, though, we start to — and have to — think about other things, from what we’re doing at work to what we’re buying for dinner. As the thing that shocks us becomes just one thing that we focus on, rather than the one thing that we focus on,, our emotions settle. Or they do to a certain extent, anyway. The big thing is still a big thing. We’re never able to ignore it for long, nor should we.

So we need other tools to help us deal with troubling feelings.

There are more good people than bad people

Many people have been seeking useful perspectives that help them to feel calmer. In another post here I suggested it was helpful to recognize that we are not alone in a sea of terrible people, which is what we might at first think. Most people who voted did not vote for Donald Trump, and that many of them don’t even support his policies. They were simply expressing dissatisfaction with the current economy, often for very legitimate reasons. Many were misinformed and didn’t know what exactly  what they were voting for. After all, we never do. Elections are a statement of hope. Sometimes things work out better than usual. Sometimes we’re disappointed. Perhaps you were overjoyed with the election results. I hope you don’t come to regret that, although I suspect you will.

It’s reassuring to consider that many people were low-information voters rather than supporters of authoritarianism. Many of the people who supported him don’t know what “authoritarianism” meant (it was a Republican who pointed this out). And some of them think of authoritarian leadership as no big deal (they’re just “owning the libs”) not realizing that authoritarian regimes can be hard to remove from power and inevitably do immense harm while they exist.

So that was one strategy for helping to calm the anxious mind; remembering there are lots of good people around us, some of whom are merely misguided rather than monsters. True authoritarians are found in all societies, but are a minority — perhaps thirty percent of the population in the US, meaning that seventy percent are not.

Self-compassion for political feelings

As another strategy for calming emotions, I’ve been encouraging people to practice compassion: first for themselves, and then for others.

We may be feeling grief, or panic, or fear. I suggest that we surround those feelings with a space of kindness and compassion, and then live from that space.

These troubling feelings are often around the diaphragm or heart. They are unpleasant, and this can make us want to avoid them. But that’s the worst thing we can do. We need to accept them. This can mean a number of things:

  • Remembering that in being in pain or discomfort we are not failing. Pain is a normal part of life.
  • Seeing these feelings simply as sensations like any other.
  • Breathing with the discomfort.
  • Telling ourselves, “It’s okay to feel this. Let me feel this.”
  • Seeing them as communications from a part of us that needs our support.

We can do all of these things. The more tools the better. The last one, though — seeing them as communications from a part of us that needs our support — is crucial.

The nature of feelings

Feelings arise from relatively ancient parts of the brain. They act as a communication when potentially harmful circumstances are detected. And the election of someone who has values conflict with our own, and who wants to enact those values through policies we consider harmful, is such a threat. Hence, these ancient systems send a signal into the body, alerting our whole system to the perceived threat.

The part of us that is alarmed is just part of us. There is a part that is afraid, but there are also parts that can offer it reassurance. The problem is, when we are panicking we don’t even realize that we have this self-reassuring capability.

Seeing with kindness

To trigger it, we have to mentally step back. We need to step, imaginatively, into a different time and place. Into a safer space. So try remembering, right now, a time you looked with love and affection. (I’m remembering what it was like to watch my children sleeping when they were young. You can recall looking at a child, a lover, a partner, a friend, a pet — it doesn’t matter as long as you’re immersing yourself in a memory of love.)

As you bear this memory in mind, feel the qualities that arise in your sense of vision. Feel what’s happening in and around the eyes. Notice qualities of softness, warmth, cherishing, tenderness, love. And then turn your attention — imbued with those same qualities — inward, toward your own feelings of dread, or anxiety, or grief, or whatever they may be.

Regard your painful feelings with loving eyes.

Talking to yourself compassionately

And talk to those feelings, or to the ancient parts of the brain that create them, with kind, reassuring words. Say things like:

  • It’s okay. I’m here for you.
  • I care about you and I want you to be at ease.
  • I know this is hard, but I’ll take care of you.
  • We’ll get through this together.

With this combination of regarding our pain with loving eyes, and offering supportive messages, we’re offering ourselves a lot of reassurance. This helps to calm down our emotional responses and make them more manageable.

But it does more than that. While before, it seemed like our painful feelings dominated our experience and were who we are (or as the Buddha put it, we sensed ourselves as “conjoined with them”) now our feelings are just one part of our experience.

Living from a space of compassion

Surrounding our feelings is a space of warmth, compassion, and stillness. And we are relating to our pain from that space. We feel ourselves securely in this compassionate space, regarding our painful feelings with empathy and warmth, offering them support. This is  much better! We can feel comfortable with our discomfort.

But we can go further. Not only do we relate to our own painful feelings with compassion, but we can also relate to others’ pain with compassion. Aware that there are others out there in the world, suffering as we had been suffering. And we can regard them with empathetic, loving, supportive eyes. And we can think supportive thoughts.

And this helps us with our own suffering, because we’re no longer focusing narrowly on ourselves, and we’re aware we’re all in it together.

Taking compassion into our actions

But we can go further than that, do. Feeling compassion is hollow if it doesn’t lead to acts of compassion. So find something to do. Maybe it’s as simple as reaching out to some friends and letting them know they’re not alone. Maybe it’s donating to one of the many organizations we’re going to need if things get really bad. Maybe it’s attending a vigil or demonstration. Maybe it’s starting or joining a book discussion group, reading something like Timothy Snyder’s “On Tyranny” together.

Doing something gives us a sense of power, of agency. It makes us feel stronger and less fearful.

So in this way, having created a space of compassion around our pain, we live from that space, both in an inward direction, supporting what is suffering within us, and in an outward direction, offering support to others and strengthening the fabric of civil society.

Bodhipaksa

Wildmind is a Community-Supported Meditation Initiative. Click here to find out about the many benefits of being a sponsor.

Read More

Politics as a spiritual practice

Image of a standing buddha statue seen from behin, overlooking an urban landscape. To the left are the words "Politics as a spiritual practice."

I don’t normally post about politics here, but I feel I have to today, because a lot of people are distressed, shocked, and fearful. Even though the results of yesterday’s US election are not yet fully in, it’s clear that Donald Trump will be our next president.

I did not know what to expect with the US election. I thought it was possible that Trump might scrape to a narrow victory. I hoped, though, that Harris would would win, narrowly or (I scarcely dared dream it) by a landslide. I feared that if Harris did win, that the election would be disputed and that some Republican-controlled states might attempt to overturn the election results.

I had not expected Trump to win resoundingly, with a majority of the votes. [Later edit: not a majority! Slightly less than 50% of the votes cast.] (In 2016 Hillary Clinton got five million more votes than he did.) I think we’re fortunate that the election was not disputed, and that there was no attempt to overturn the vote.

At the moment I feel quite calm. My poor partner did not sleep a wink.

I am for once grateful that in the US system the victor does not take power immediately (unlike in the UK where the Prime Minister moves out of Downing Street the day after the election). So there’s a sense of normality at present. That won’t last, though.

It’s impossible to know what’s coming. Trump himself is just one part of things. He’s vindictive, petty, vain, and impulsive. He’s easily manipulated by those around him. Last time he was in office he was surrounded by people who, although not saints, were at least better than he was. With a small number of exceptions, those people have repudiated him and said he’s unfit for office. Two of them described him as a fascist. He’s now likely to be surrounded by people who are much worse than he is. It’s likely they’ll encourage his worst instincts and that we’ll see some very bad things happening.

Normally you prepare to ride out four difficult years until the next election. This time we’re facing potentially catastrophic demolition of the mechanisms that preserve democracy, a collapsed economy, the partial restoration of the Soviet Union, and an acceleration of climate change.

There may not be another totally free and fair election for a long time, and even if decent people are elected in the future, what they inherit may not be fixable. But they’ll have to do what they can with what’s left. It’s possible that there may be a re-founding of the United States, if there is a United States in the future. A catastrophic collapse gives the opportunity to learn from the past and to avoid its mistakes. The US constitution and its laws have been manifestly “unfit for purpose” as they say in the UK. The fact that Donald Trump is heading for the White House rather than prison is just one illustration of that.

I find it important to remember that many of those who voted for Trump did not know what they were voting for. Many are struggling in an economy that favors the ultra-rich and largely ignores ordinary people. They wanted a change. Right wing channel news networks manipulate and dis-inform. They think inflation is at an all-time high when it’s not. They think crime is rampant, when it’s falling. They think their way of life is under threat from immigrants, when they are themselves the children of immigrants and depend on immigrants to do basic tasks that keep the economy running.

Many of those people did not know they were voting for a man who says he wants his generals to be like Hitler’s generals, and that he wants to use the US military against the civilian population. Or they’d heard this and thought it was propaganda. Or they thought it was just Trump trolling the libs. But many of the people working for Trump do not think it’s just Trump trolling. Some of them want violent oppression of all opposition.

Some people showed up to vote yesterday not knowing that Biden had dropped out of the race. A study showed that a mild Covid infection reduces a person’s IQ by three points. A more severe case with lingering symptoms causes a six-point drop. If hospitalization is required, the drop is nine points. That’s from a single infection. Presumably repeated infections cause further cognitive damage.

The population has literally been been dumbed down. I say this not as an insult (I’ve had Covid and an not immune to its cognitive effects). I say this because it may well be part of how we got to where we are.

In short, many people who voted for a man who has been called a “fascist” by people who worked closely with him have no idea what they’ve just done. They are not our enemy, and they deserve our compassion. (Others are enemies in the sense that they want to harm us, but we need not hate them in return. It’s a myth that you can’t oppose someone without also hating them.)

I find it important to remember that there are many people in the US (and elsewhere, of course) who believe in kindness, generosity, tolerance, compassion, democracy, standing up to autocrats, and protecting the world that sustains us. That’s much more than half of the population.

We are the majority.

I find it important to remember that fascist regimes (and it looks like that’s what we’ll end up with) always collapse. The “strong man” is emotionally fragile and cannot stand contradiction. So he doesn’t listen to critics on his own side, and his actions eventually bring things crashing down.

It’s likely that there will be a series of brutal moves following the transfer of power. These will be designed to intimidate, demoralize, and traumatize anyone who opposes the Trump administration.

We’re going to need to find ways to hold onto our faith when this happens.

We’re going to need to find ways to sustain that faith, and to sustain our kindness, compassion, tolerance, and belief in democracy for much longer than four years.

The best way to do that is to be actively involved in some organization that represents your values. Being engaged with like-minded people helps us feel strong. Doing something that makes a difference helps us feel strong.

I suggest we all start looking for ways to get involved, if we’re not already.

In the meantime, I highly recommend reading Timothy Snyder’s “On Tyranny.” Snyder is a history professor who studies autocracy. On Tyranny is a small book, easy to read, and simply written. It’s a guide-book to surviving fascism, and on keeping alive positive values through dark times.

I strongly suggest that you do NOT buy this book from Amazon, which is owned by a billionaire. People like Jeff Bezos have a lot to gain (in the short term) from an illiberal regime. (The day Bezos announced that the Washington Post would not endorse either candidate, he was reportedly in negotiations with Trump about the government using his rockets.) These people are not your friends. Don’t support them.

Instead, support a local book shop. Support ordinary people. Support your neighbors. Live your values.

If you don’t have a local bookshop or can’t get to one, try bookshop.org in the US, Hive in the UK, or look for some other independent outlet where you live.

If everything gets reduced to what’s most convenient (“one click purchasing”) you’re not living your values. The essence of ethics is doing things that are less convenient. It’s slightly harder in the short term. But it feels good in the long term.

We are the majority. It’s imperative that we stick together.

A couple of years ago I taught an online course called “Politics as a Spiritual Practice,” which is where the graphic above comes from. I do think it’s vital that we don’t just “do politics” but that we see our engagement with politics as a vehicle for developing patience, courage, compassion, and wisdom. The next four or more years are going to test us. Those tests can potentially make us better people. And we’re going to need better people to rebuild whatever we’re left with.

Read More

The Tibetans of Ervance

I recently came across a beautifully written article by Sam Kriss, who I’d never heard of before. I was struck by how beautifully and intelligently he wrote. That led me to his Substack blog, Numb at the Lodge, where I noticed that one article was illustrated with an image of a wrathful Tibetan deity. Only part of the article concerned Tibetan Buddhism, and I’ve reproduced that section here. I hope you enjoy it, and that it leads you to read more of Sam’s work.

In his Tribune column from October 13th, 1944, George Orwell tells an interesting story. During the liberation of France, the Allies were capturing large numbers of not just German troops, but soldiers from many other countries pressed into service by the Wehrmacht. Among them were large numbers of anti-Soviet Russians, but Orwell’s informant had heard about two soldiers from somewhere much deeper in the great centre of Asia, who spoke no Russian or any other language known to their British captors. ‘A professor of Slavonic languages, brought down from Oxford, could make nothing of what they were saying. Then it happened that a sergeant who had served on the frontiers of India overheard them talking and recognized their language, which he was able to speak a little. It was Tibetan!’ Somehow, these wandering Tibetans had come down from their plateau, fallen into the hands of the Soviets, conscripted, captured by the Germans, and forced to man the defences in Normandy. The two men had fought on both sides of the biggest war in human history, but ‘all this time they had been able to speak to nobody but one another, and had no notion of what was happening or who was fighting whom.’

In Cambodia, Brian Fawcett provides some further details. The two Tibetans were peasants from Gyêgumdo in what’s now the Chinese province of Qinghai. They’d been making a pilgrimage to Lhasa, where they were planning to join a monastery. However, they got caught in a snowstorm, lost their bearings, and strayed into China. They were captured by bandits along the Lancan River, who headed north to join the Communists in Yan’an. At some point the Tibetans escaped and wandered aimlessly through the parched wildernesses until they were finally picked up by the Soviet authorities in Tashkent, given a rifle, and told to defend the socialist motherland against fascism. Fawcett provides one important addition to Orwell’s story: the answer to ‘the riddle of their unlikely survival and their profound, elastic passivity in the face of hardship after hardship.’ He explains that ‘for ten years, these two men had believed that they were dead… They had survived because from the very first days of their ordeal they believed they were dead men caught in an unpredictable bardo, or netherworld.’

[…]

Both Orwell and Fawcett miss some significant details in the story of the wandering Tibetans. The two Tibetans were interned by the British at Château Ervance, which had previously been an SS fortress and was now a major Allied POW camp. And the translation was not provided by some old India hand, but by a fellow captive: SS-Sturmbannführer Otto Gosse. In 1938, Gosse had joined Ernst Schäfer’s SS expedition to Tibet, possibly to seek out the mystical kingdom of Agartha and the birthplace of the Aryan race, probably just to assess the Tibetan plateau as a possible staging ground for an eventual invasion of British India. During the trip, he had picked up a rough working knowledge of Tibetan, and a profound distaste for Nyingma Buddhism. Gosse grumbled that the Tibetan these men spoke was atonal and antiquated, more like the thousand-year-old language of the Gyubum than the ordinary speech he’d actually encountered up on the plateau. But he could make himself understood. Through Gosse, the British officers tried to explain to the Tibetans that they were not dead but actually just in a very distant country called France, and if they wanted, the British would provide them with passports so they could return to Gyêgumdo. The Tibetans said no.

A bardo is not quite the same as a netherworld: ordinary waking life is a bardo state; dreams take place in another. There is a bardo accessible through meditative trance. But the bardo the two peasants had found themselves in was the sidpa bardo, the bardo of becoming, the one we experience after death. Sidpa bardo is the interzone between one life and the next, the junkyard of earthly existence, packed with the detritus and runoff of worlds. This is where gods and buddhas take on their fearsome forms, and to pass through sidpa bardo involves suffering many frightening visions. Because this bardo state is made of unstructured waste-thought leaking out from all other bardos, it is always flickering, impermanent. You will see a world you do not understand, and you will see it in ruins. Every city you pass through is bombed. Every person you meet falls dead in battle. You will be attacked by demons and wild animals. But sidpa bardo is educative; the point of these visions is to prepare you for being born again. The entire Second World War had been fought solely to teach these two Tibetan peasants some secret for their next life. They believed they had learned that secret. They had no interest in returning to Gyêgumdo. They did not want the war to have been in vain.

Kriss has written some excellent satire, and my first thought was that he was inventing sources to create this amazing story, but I checked Orwell’s Tribune column for October 13 1944, and he does indeed discuss the story of the two Tibetans who ended up fighting for both sides in WWII, without having any understanding of what was going on. Based on that, I assume that the rest of Kriss’s account is accurate as well.

Read More

New translations of “This Difficult Thing of Being Human”

this difficult thing, chinese and korean editions

I was delighted to discover recently that “This Difficult Thing of Being Human” — my book on self-compassion — has been translated into Chinese and Korean. That’s in addition to a Romanian translation I learned about three years ago.

It’s an odd story. I discovered the Romanian translation by accident while browsing on Amazon. I saw my name on the cover of a book but didn’t recognize the title or even the language it was in. Google Translate helped me determine that the book was in Romanian. I asked my editor about this, and yes, it was legit. They’d made a deal with a Romanian publishing company, and had forgotten to tell me. My editor also mentioned that there was possibly a Chinese translation coming out as well.

I promptly forgot about the Chinese translation until a couple of months ago, when I happened to re-read that email while looking for something else.

I asked my publisher if anything had happened with that, and the editor I talked to didn’t know. The person who would no was on extended leave. Two months later they got back to me and told me that the Chinese translation not only existed, but had been published two years ago! That was a surprise!

I was curious about the money side of this and continued the conversation. Then someone in the company mentioned “the Korean translation.” The Korean translation??? I asked for more information, but I found it through searching online before I got a reply.

It’s funny how authors seem to be the least important part of the publishing industry!

Looking for an image of the cover of the Korean translation, I found a review that was really beautifully done, with photographs of the book beside some meticulous hand-written notes. (The link is to a Google translation of the review.)

Image of Korean version of This Difficult Thing of Being Human, beside an open notebook of hand-written notes

I haven’t actually seen copies of these books, but I hope that my publisher will be able to track one down and give it to me. Otherwise I’ll have to buy my own books and have them shipped from Asia. (See what I mean about authors being the least important part of the publishing industry?)

Here are links to:

請用正念疼惜自己 (Chinese)

and

인간으로 산다는, 그 어려운 일 (Korean)

I believe that’s nine languages that my books are now available in: English, French, German, Spanish, Finnish, Romanian, Taiwanese, Chinese, and Korean. It would be nice to get that up into double figures.

Read More

Understanding non-self – an audio preview

An old wooden chair sitting in front of an old stone wall.

I’m curious what you think about this conversation, on the topic of non-self. It’s a podcast-style explanation of an article I wrote years ago, called Understanding Non-Self: The boys in the basement, the empty room, and the plagiarist.

I was fairly pleased with the conversation. I think the two people did a good job of drawing out some of the main points. And they said some nice things about me. Here’s the recording.

What did you think?

The interesting thing is that these are not real people. The conversation was generated entirely by a Google AI. All I did was feed it a PDF of my article, and it created the script and voiced it.

In case you’re wondering, the complimentary things the AI says about me are not from me. I suspect it’s also gathering information from the web.

I know some people like listening to things rather than reading. I suspect some of those folks would be inclined to read an article after having heard about it. So I’m wondering if perhaps I might create some more of these dialogs, and use them as a way to draw more readers into this blog.

Also see:

I have very mixed feelings about AI. Some uses are just horrendous, and unfortunately it’s putting people outAri of work. Sometimes it gives inaccurate and even dangerous advice. AI companies shamelessly steal content. This seems one of the more benign uses, although I do wonder about the carbon footprint.

Anyway, once again, here’s a link to the article that’s being discussed.

Read More

12 Ways to respond to unkindness with kindness

infographic: 12 WAYS TO RESPOND TO UNKINDNESS WITH KINDNESS UNDERSTAND THE SOURCE Unkind behavior often stems from the other person's struggles or insecurities. This can help you respond with empathy. RESPOND WITH EMPATHY show understanding and compassion, even if you disagree with the other person. MAINTAIN COMPOSURE Stay calm and do not to take unkind behavior personally. This allows you to respond thoughtfully rather than react emotionally. USE POSITIVE LANGUAGE Avoidneratis words constructive, positive communication. TAKE A DEEP BREATH Before responding, take a moment to breathe deeply, which can help regain composure. PRACTICE ACTIVE LISTENING Try to understand the other person's point of view without immediately jumping to conclusions. SET BOUNDARIES Kindness does not mean tolerating abuse or disrespect. Set clear boundaries when necessary. SEEK COMMON GROUND Find areas of agreement or shared interests as a foundation for positive interaction. OFFER HELP Sometimes, unkind behavior is a cry for help. Helping can be a powerful response. DO NOT RETALIATE Avoid the temptation to respond in kind. Retaliation only perpetuates the cycle of unkindness. PRACTICE FORGIVENESS Holding onto anger or resentment harms you more than it affects the other person. Forgiveness can be liberating. REFLECT AND LEARN After the interaction, reflect on what happened and consider ways to improve future responses.

I came across this on Mastodon (the BEST social media platform), shared by user Vee, and thought it was really useful. I haven’t been able to find out for sure where it’s from, but it seems to be from a company called HackingHR.

Here’s what it says:

UNDERSTAND THE SOURCE

Unkind behavior often stems from the other person’s struggles or insecurities. This can help you respond with empathy.

RESPOND WITH EMPATHY

Show understanding and compassion, even if you disagree with the other person.

MAINTAIN COMPOSURE

Stay calm and do not to take unkind behavior personally. This allows you to respond thoughtfully rather than react emotionally.

USE POSITIVE LANGUAGE

Avoid negative words and focus on constructive, positive communication.

TAKE A DEEP BREATH

Before responding, take a moment to breathe deeply, which can help regain composure.

PRACTICE ACTIVE LISTENING

Try to understand the other person’s point of view without immediately jumping to conclusions.

SET BOUNDARIES

Kindness does not mean tolerating abuse or disrespect. Set clear boundaries when necessary.

SEEK COMMON GROUND

Find areas of agreement or shared interests as a foundation for positive interaction.

OFFER HELP

Sometimes, unkind behavior is a cry for help. Helping can be a powerful response.

DO NOT RETALIATE

Avoid the temptation to respond in kind. Retaliation only perpetuates the cycle of unkindness.

PRACTICE FORGIVENESS

Holding onto anger or resentment harms you more than it affects the other person. Forgiveness can be liberating.

REFLECT AND LEARN

After the interaction, reflect on what happened and consider ways to improve future responses.

Read More

Great news about my writing

Bodhipaksa in his office, with a thangka, flowers, and buddha statue in the background

Exciting things have been happening recently. In the space of just a week or so I was been offered two publishing contracts, one for a book coming out next year, and one for the following year.

“The Heart’s Awakening”

The Heart’s Awakening” is scheduled to come out in September 2025, and is being published by Windhorse Publications.

The book is based on four courses I created on the topic of the Brahmaviharas, which are practices for bringing more kindness, compassion, and appreciation into our lives. In these courses I radically re-imagine these practices. For example,

  • I explore metta as kindness, rather than lovingkindness, the former term being much more down-to-earth and experiential.
  • I stress the necessity for developing empathy before cultivating kindness.
  • I place a lot of emphasis on self-compassion as a prerequisite for having compassion for others (something I also explore in my book, “This Difficult Thing of Being Human.”)
  • I discuss mudita not as “sympathetic joy” but as joyful appreciation of what’s skillful.
  • And I discuss upekkha not as a state of withdrawal into peace, but as a calming of reactivity so that we can love more deeply.

“SIT: 28 Days to a Rock-Solid Daily Meditation Practice”

The second book is  based on my course, “Get Your Sit Together.” It’s coming out through Wisdom Publications in the Spring of 2026. The title is self-explanatory. It is aimed at people who have been practicing for a while — perhaps years — but who have never managed to establish an unshakable daily practice. It comes out of my own struggles with this, and from my work in helping others to establish a rock-solid daily meditation practice.

This is all very affirming, and I’m thrilled that the work I’m doing will reach and benefit a wider audience. I will of course let you all know when these two titles are available for pre-order.

Read More

“Unyoking” ourselves from feelings

Isolated cloud, partly in shadow, in a slate-gray sky.

Feelings are a very ancient part of us. They are evolution’s first attempt at thought. While conceptual thought takes place in the mind, feelings take place in the body. While thoughts are in general mainly visual and auditory representations of external events, feelings are kinesthetic representations of sensations. So we talk about having a heavy heart, as if sorrow is a burden we physically carry, or feel a dropping sensation when we’re disappointed, like a tree-dwelling primate discovering that a branch will not bear its weight, or we feel warm toward someone, as if we were physically in contact with them. (I suspect that most, if not all, our feelings mimic actual dangers and benefits our early ancestors encountered.)

Feelings, like thoughts, are interpretations of reality rather than reality itself. Feelings are meant to indicate whether things we perceive are potential threats, benefits, or are neither. When the mind has interpreted something as a potential threat, our feelings are unpleasant. This motivates us to withdraw, freeze, fight, or push something away. When the mind considers something to be a potential benefit, we have pleasant feelings, which motivate us to move closer, or to hold on. When something seems to have no relevance to our well-being, we feel nothing. We usually ignore things that fall into this category.

Also see:

Although both thoughts and feelings are inner presentations created in order to help us navigate life, feelings are often much more effective motivators than their more recently evolved cousins, thoughts. What feelings lack in subtlety, they more than make up for in brute force. Have you ever tried getting someone to taste a new food, and they just won’t do it? “Try this,” you say, “it’s delicious!” Your friend, their expression somewhere between skeptical and disgust, refuses. You try again, “Really, this is wonderful! You must try it!” Your friend is unmoved, because your words carry almost no force compared to the feelings they are in the grip of — feelings that tell them not to risk trying something they might not like. Our feelings act like they’re our boss, and we tend to go along with them, assuming that we’re their servant.

Unfortunately, being part of our ancient wiring, feelings aren’t necessarily very wise when it comes to directing our actions. We often avoid doing things that are good for us, because our feelings indicate that something bad will happen if we do. Think of the essential phone call you keep putting off. Even though intellectually you know that there will be unpleasant consequences from the delay, your heart sinks when you think about it, and your resistance is like running into a brick wall). We also do things despite knowing they are bad for us, because our feelings tell us they’re beneficial. Think of “eating your feelings.”

(Sometimes our feelings can be very wise indeed, though. You can have a feeling that someone is not to be trusted, even though you can’t pinpoint why. Such a feeling can save your life.) A substantial part of our spiritual practice involves learning not to let our feelings be our boss, but instead to learning to see them as advisors whose advice may be good or bad, and that we can pick or choose from.

The Buddha talked about the unwise person becoming emotionally reactive because they are “yoked” (saññutta) to their feelings. They don’t experience any sense of separation between their sense of self and the feelings they experience. And this is how we are most of the time when we react to other people with anger, hatred, or contempt — when our love fails. We are yoked to our feelings so that when they go one way, so do we. In an effort to disengage from unskillful emotions towards others, we can give our feelings space, observe their impermanence, look so closely at them that we start to see them as insubstantial, and engage in “creative reductionism” so that we simply see them as pleasant and unpleasant. But seeing them as not being part of us is another very powerful technique that can allow us to move from conflict, to peace, and thence to love.

Imagine a blue sky. In it, due to the prevailing weather conditions, gradually appears a single, white cloud. If you watch the cloud carefully you’ll see that it’s constantly changing shape, evolving, dissolving in some places and materializing in others. After a time, the cloud dissolves completely, and we are left once more with a clear blue expanse. We can see this as an example of impermanence, but we can also ask the question, “Was the cloud intrinsically part of the sky?” Of course it wasn’t. The sky was there before the cloud appeared, and remained after the cloud had gone. Even if the clouds completely obscure the blue for a while, they are never truly part of the sky.

It’s just the same with our feelings. They appear when conditions are right. They constantly change while they’re in existence. Eventually, they pass away. Yet your being—an ever-changing and indefinable stream of materiality, energy, feeling, thought, and emotion—remains. The feeling was never an intrinsic part of you. It was just a temporary phenomenon, ever-changing as it passed through you on its way from non-existence to nothingness.

We can see that our feelings don’t even arise entirely in dependence on ourselves. Instead, they result from the meeting of whatever-it-is-we-are with the world. They are co-creations of “self” and world. (Yes, feelings can arise from our thoughts, but our thoughts are in turn derived from, and are representations of, the world.)

Feelings are not consciously created. You don’t make them happen. They come from ancient parts of the mind that are inaccessible to conscious awareness, and they are simply received. You feel feelings in the same way as you hear sounds: they are delivered to you.

Neither can you will them out of existence. You can’t simply dispel depression or anxiety by saying, “Begone, unwanted feeling!” How can something that you simply receive, and can’t control, be “you”? This is what the Buddha was talking about when he said:

Form is not yourself. For if form were yourself, it wouldn’t lead to affliction. And you could compel form: ‘May my form be like this! May it not be like that!’ But because form is not yourself, it leads to affliction. And you can’t compel form: ‘May my form be like this! May it not be like that!’

Feelings being insubstantial, there is nothing there for us to hold onto. We can call them “our” feelings but we can never possess them. How can something we can never hold onto be “us”?

Talking or reading about all this is one thing. Maybe it’s puzzling. Maybe it’s frustrating. Maybe it gives rise to feelings of resistance. The thing is, this is a practice. It’s not an intellectual exercise. The point is to practice observing. Get beneath your intellectuality, and see what’s really there. Be mindful.

Observe feelings as objects of attention. Let yourself notice their coming-into-being and their going-out-of-being. Notice how you do not choose them, and how instead they simply arise. Unyoking yourself from them, notice how you do not have to go in the direction they are trying to take you. An unpleasant feeling does not need to make you react with aversion, nor does a pleasant feeling have to lead you into craving or grasping. Your feelings are advice, not commands. You don’t have to let them be your boss. Let your feelings be, and remain free.

Lastly, as you observe feelings you can remind yourself, as the Buddha advised many times, “This is not mine, I am not this, this is not my self.” This is a powerful yet underused tool.

The thing is to keep looking, observing, reflecting. This is our practice. If we do that, then we will start to recognize that our feelings — and everything else that makes up whatever-this-is — are not ours, not us, not who we are. Then we’re a step closer to awakening. We’re a step closer to dismantling this obstacle that is our belief in a separate self. We can disentangle ourselves from the anger, hatred, resentment, and contempt that cause our love to fail. We can return to loving, and as we do so we can realize that others, caught up in delusion, are yoked to their own feelings, and we can desire that they be free as well.

When we free ourselves, we naturally want to free others.

Read More

Mudita is not “sympathetic joy”

Person kneeling in front of a giant Buddha statue in a temple

This is an extract from the introduction to my current course on Mudita, which is part of a longer series of teachings on the brahma-viharas — also known as the “immeasurables.”


The third of the Brahmaviharas, after lovingkindness and compassion, is mudita. Mudita is usually translated as sympathetic or empathetic joy, and is described as “feeling happy because others are happy.”

This is an interpretation I profoundly disagree with.

A first century text called the Path to Freedom describes the cultivation of mudita like this:

When one sees or hears that some person’s qualities are esteemed by others, and that he is at peace and is joyful, one thinks thus: “Sadhu! Sadhu! May he continue joyful for a long time!”

(Sādhu, by the way, means something like “Yay!” or “Alright!” or “Great!”)

The records we have of the Buddha’s teachings don’t define mudita, and the text above is the earliest I know of that gives us an indication of what mudita is and how it’s to be cultivated. There are several things that are significant here.

  • We’re asked to call to mind someone whose skillful qualities are developed to the point where others esteem them. Having mudita involves recognizing what’s skillful.
  • We’re not just being asked to call to mind someone who is happy, but someone who is happy (and at peace) as a result of having those skillful qualities. So when we have mudita we see the connection between skillful actions and their beneficial results.
  • Appreciation is involved. We appreciate skillful qualities, and the peace and joy they bring, as being good things.
  • Love is involved. Because we want what is good for them, we encourage this person’s future joy and happiness, by supporting, rejoicing in, and encouraging their skillfulness.
  • By valuing this other person’s skillfulness, and the peace and joy that come from it, we ourselves become joyful. So we’re cultivating a state of appreciation that’s joyful.

This all goes far, far beyond “being happy because someone is happy.” That much more mundane experience is actually fraught with spiritual difficulties, because a lot of the apparent happiness we see around us arises on the basis of unskillful actions. We shouldn’t be glad that someone is happy because they’ve just defrauded an old lady of her life savings, for example.

In summary, when we practice mudita we appreciate skillful attributes, speech, and actions, and this brings joy. And so mudita is “joyful appreciation.”

A Progression

There is a progression in the first three brahma-viharas.

Metta is kindness. We want what is best for others’ long-term happiness and well-being. We want them to be happy. We want them to feel supported and to know that they matter. We speak and act kindly, and think about others kindly as well.

Karuna, or compassion, is what happens when we want beings to be happy but are aware that they are suffering. In order for them to be happy we want to remove their suffering, or at least support them while the suffering persists.

When we have mudita we want others to be happy, but now we recognize that happiness is not something that happens randomly. The happiness we’re interested in is the kind that comes from having skillful qualities. And so, wanting beings to be happy, we recognize the skillful qualities within them that give rise to happiness, and we appreciate, rejoice in, and encourage the development of those qualities.

To have mudita we have to be able to recognize conditionality, which is the way in which certain conditions and actions give rise to suffering, while others free us from suffering. Mudita is therefore at least in part a wisdom practice.

Just as we can define compassion as metta meeting suffering, we can define mudita as metta meeting skillfulness. This meeting is a joyful experience, or at least is capable of arousing joy.

The Stages of the Mudita Practice

As with the lovingkindness and compassion practices, there are five stages in joyful appreciation meditation.

  1. We start with cultivating appreciation of ourselves, or at least establish kindness towards ourselves. This stage is not found in the earliest description of the practice, but is a healthy place to begin, given that many of us often lack appreciation of our own skillful qualities.
  2. We then call to mind a person who embodies skillful qualities and experiences peace and joy as a result.
  3. Then we do this for a relative stranger (“neutral person”).
  4. Then for person we have difficulty with.
  5. And then finally we wish that all beings develop skillful qualities and experience calm and joy as a result.

As with the compassion practice, there is no “friend” stage. The person with skillful qualities in the second stage may be a friend, or we can include friends in the final stage.

For the first few days, we’re going to focus on self-appreciation.

Today I’ve chosen an exercise from “Living With Appreciation.” It’s on “Taking time to savor the positive..” The guidance begins with a short talk and is 10 minutes long in total.

Meditation Isn’t Enough

Although mudita bhavana is a meditation practice, developing joyful appreciation is something we can and should do in daily life as well. We can recognize skillful words and actions that we encounter, and we can also be more generally appreciative — recognizing and being glad for anything whatsoever that bring benefits to us or others.

An Exercise

Today, carry around an attitude of appreciation as best you can. As you encounter others, or even just think of them, be aware that they contain the seeds of goodness. When good things happen to you, however minor they seem dwell on them appreciatively.

Bodhipaksa

Wildmind is a Community-Supported Meditation Initiative. Click here to find out about the many benefits of being a sponsor.

Shares are currently $8 per month.

Read More

Forgiveness as a practice of compassion

A post-it note on a wooden desk, reading "sorry"

One of the emotional drivers of cruel and unkind behavior is resentment. Resentment is when we hold onto past hurt, locking ourselves into a pattern of blame. Unable to let go of the past we keep bringing up a memory of someone hurting us, betraying us, or failing to protect us. Every time we do so we experience the hurt anew. And every time we hurt ourselves we feel a renewed burst of ill will.

There’s something about this that I’d like to clear up, and that’s the misapprehension that we somehow store old emotions in the subconscious, from where they make appearances from time to time. This model dates back to Freud, at least, and is based on a model of emotion that we now know to be wrong. It’s a tempting view, however, especially given that we often, as I’ve described above, experience the hurt accompanying an old memory. But what’s actually happening, according both to Buddhist teachings on the mind and modern psychology, is that the feeling of hurt is being recreated over and over again, every time that the memory is triggered. Every time you feel the hurt, it’s a new hurt. Every time the hurt gives rise to anger or self-hatred, it’s a new emotion that you’re experiencing.

Also see:

We get trapped in cycles of resentment instinctively. It’s not exactly something we plan to do. It’s a habit we share with other animals. A favorite example of mine is crows, who develop resentment against researchers who have caged and banded them. They can maintain these attitudes—which involve scolding calls, accompanied by wing- and tail-flicking, and mobbing—for years. The signs of resentment they show spread through entire communities and can grow over time as new members of the community learn from others.

The example of the crows is a good reminder that we don’t choose to have resentment as part of our emotional make-up. It’s part of our genetic inheritance. And so it’s pointless and needlessly painful for us to blame ourselves for the mere fact of being prone to resentment.

We can also learn from the crows that resentment is about both punishment and protection. We want to punish those who have hurt us or those close to us. We want them to know they have done something unacceptable. The aim is to stop them from repeating the hurtful act. We’re trying to change their behavior. (Notice that we’re once more back to Punishment Culture.)

Resentment can be painful for those it’s directed at, but it’s certainly painful for us. In fact in many cases it causes us far more suffering than it causes the other person. There’s a saying in AA that resentment is like swallowing rat poison and waiting for the other person to die. A much older saying from the Buddhist tradition is that resentment is like picking up feces to throw it at another person; you might make them smell but the only person guaranteed to be punished is yourself.

These are useful reflections to bear in mind, because they help make resentment look less attractive. When we catch ourselves in the midst of resentful reactivity, we can help weaken the emotion by reminding ourselves of its consequences.

Forgiveness is the opposite of resentment. Forgiveness is a willingness to let go of ill will. And we can do this both because we want to stop hurting another person and because we want to stop hurting ourselves.

It can hard for us to forgive because we think that to keep ourselves safe we have to keep reminding the other person that they have transgressed so that they don’t do it again, and we have to keep reminding ourselves that this person has the capacity to hurt or harm us. For the first part of that we maybe need to ask ourselves, how much punishment is enough if we want the other person to know we’re upset that they hurt us? Do they already know? If not, will they ever? What would you need from them in order to be sure? Might you have already received it? Or received as much as you’re going to get? Is maintaining the resentment worth the pain you’re causing yourself?

It’s good to remember that you don’t need ill will to protect yourself from another person. If they have the potential to hurt you, you can simply know that, and be on the look-out for signs that they might do so. You can keep your guard up (if that’s needed) without hatred or resentment, simply by knowing. You can trust yourself on this.

However you don’t have to trust the other person. if they’re untrustworthy, remember that. Don’t give them your trust. Resentment doesn’t need to be involved.

Having talked about untrustworthy people who want to hurt or harm us, in my experience a lot of resentment is against people who have no ongoing desire to do us wrong. They may even be people we love and who love us. Especially in those cases, since loving relationships are so precious, I suggest being quick to forgive.

The self-compassion practices I’ve outlined are ideal for helping us let go of resentments:

  1. Recognize you’re causing yourself suffering.
  2. Drop the resentful story.
  3. Drop down into the body, find your pain, and accept it.
  4. Offer compassion and reassurance to the suffering part of you.

In this way you help heal the unhealed hurt, so that it ceases to ask, over and over again, to be protected by your ill will — a form of protection that can never truly protect you. Self-compassion gives our hurt the protection ill-will promises but can never deliver.

Read More
Menu

Wildmind is a Community-Supported Meditation Initiative. Explore the benefits of becoming a supporter.

Close Welcome Bar